| 1969 WR Roy Jefferson |
1970 DT Joe Greene |
1971 LB Andy Russell |
1972 RB Franco Harris |
| 1973 WR Ron Shanklin |
1974 S Glen Edwards |
1975 CB Mel Blount |
1976 LB Jack Lambert |
| 1977 QB Terry Bradshaw |
1978 QB Terry Bradshaw |
1979 WR John Stallworth |
1980 SS Donnie Shell |
| 1981 LB Jack Lambert |
1982 CB Dwayne Woodruff |
1983 PK Gary Anderson |
1984 WR John Stallworth |
| 1985 WR Louis Lipps |
1986 LB Bryan Hinkle |
1987 LB Mike Merriweather |
1988 CB Rod Woodson |
| 1989 WR Louis Lipps |
1990 CB Rod Woodson |
1991 LB Greg Lloyd |
1992 RB Barry Foster |
| 1993 CB Rod Woodson |
1994 LB Greg Lloyd |
1995 QB Neil O'Donnell |
1996 RB Jerome Bettis |
| 1997 RB Jerome Bettis |
1998 LB Levon Kirkland |
1999 LB Levon Kirkland |
2000 RB Jerome Bettis |
| 2001 QB Kordell Stewart |
2002 WR Hines Ward |
2003 WR Hines Ward |
2004 LB James Farrior |
| 2005 WR Hines Ward / DT Casey Hampton |
2006 RB Willie Parker |
2007 LB James Harrison |
2008 LB James Harrison |
| 2009 QB Ben Roethlisberger |
|
|
|